AI in schools / Doorstops

How to write a solid AI policy for your school

Find your state’s rules, see how other schools wrote theirs, and see Doorstop’s policy recommendation.

Short answer

The best AI policies use AI to further learning, not to cut corners. That means no AI on exams or to write whole essays, teachers setting clear rules for their own class, no punishing students on an AI detector’s word alone, and a review every year with students at the table.

Pick your school or state to see your state’s rules and a policy with your school’s name in it.

1

No AI on tests unless the teacher allows it, or to write whole assignments

Exams are where students show what they know, and a whole essay is where they practice thinking it through.

Real Policy Examples

  • TeachAI toolkitAI as a tutor or study aid, but not on exams unless the teacher allows it.
  • Ohio model policyEach teacher spells out AI expectations in the syllabus.

Our recommended language

Students may not use AI tools during tests, quizzes, or exams unless explicitly permitted by their teacher. Students may not use AI to complete the entirety of any written assignment.

2

Teachers decide how AI is used in their class

An art class and a chemistry lab need different rules. Teachers set them; the policy makes sure students always know what they are.

Real Policy Examples

Our recommended language

Within this policy, each teacher decides how students may use AI in their class. Teachers will state their rules in the syllabus and on any assignment where they differ, and students must follow them.

our district recommends that teachers in high schools:

(a) allow AI tools for explaining and understanding concepts;

(b) not allow AI to complete homework problems or produce answers for students;

(c) state which parts of the writing process may use AI, for example brainstorming but not drafting, or rephrasing a few sentences but not inventing arguments or conclusions; and

(d) require students to disclose any AI use on homework and essays, naming the tool and what they used it for.

our district recommends that teachers in grades K-8 do not allow any AI tools that are not explicitly authorized by the district as part of a curriculum.

3

Teachers may grade with AI, openly, with a way to appeal

AI can save teachers hours, but students deserve to know when it was used and to have a person look again.

Real Policy Examples

Our recommended language

Teachers may use AI tools to help grade student work as long as they disclose this to students.

A student who believes an AI-produced grade is unfair or incorrect may ask the teacher to review it within ten school days. If the student is still not satisfied, they may appeal to the head of the teacher’s department, who will review the work without relying on AI.

4

Every tool is vetted for privacy first

Whatever students type into a chatbot can end up stored, sold, or used to train the next model.

Real Policy Examples

Our recommended language

Only AI tools approved by our district may be used with students or student data. Before approval, each tool will be reviewed for compliance with FERPA, COPPA, and state student-privacy law. Approved vendors must agree not to use student data to train AI models or for advertising, and to delete student data on request and when the contract ends.

our district will keep a public list of approved tools.

5

AI detectors are never the only evidence

Detectors are often wrong: in one study, seven popular detectors flagged essays by non-native English speakers as AI-written 61% of the time on average.

Real Policy Examples

Our recommended language

AI-detection software may be used as one part of an academic integrity review, but a detection result cannot be the sole evidence that a student violated this policy.

Before any finding, the student will be told of the concern, shown the evidence, and given a chance to respond, for example by walking through their drafts, version history, or reasoning.

6

If AI is allowed, every student gets access

An assignment that allows AI shouldn’t reward the students who can pay for the best tools at home.

Real Policy Examples

  • Wichita, KS (P1231)If an assignment allows AI tools, they “must be made available to all students.”
  • Ohio model policyNo assignment may require a tool the district can’t provide.

Our recommended language

If AI use is allowed or required on an assignment, required tools must be made available to all students, at no cost, with time to use them at school for students who lack access at home.

7

Revisit it every year, with students, parents, and teachers

AI changes every few months. A policy from two years ago is already out of date.

Real Policy Examples

Our recommended language

The Board of Education will review this policy at least once a year. Before making meaningful changes, our district will consult students, parents and guardians, and teachers, for example through surveys, a public comment period, or an AI committee with student members.

The whole policy, ready to send

Paste it into an email to your principal or a board member, or bring it to a meeting. Edit anything in brackets.

AI policy for our district

Artificial Intelligence in Teaching and Learning

our district supports the use of artificial intelligence (AI) to further student learning, not to detract. This policy is designed to clarify boundaries for students, provide structure for teachers, and ensure any AI use respects community values on trust, authenticity, and learning.

1. Tests and essays

Students may not use AI tools during tests, quizzes, or exams unless explicitly permitted by their teacher. Students may not use AI to complete the entirety of any written assignment.

2. Classroom use

Within this policy, each teacher decides how students may use AI in their class. Teachers will state their rules in the syllabus and on any assignment where they differ, and students must follow them.

our district recommends that teachers in high schools:

(a) allow AI tools for explaining and understanding concepts;

(b) not allow AI to complete homework problems or produce answers for students;

(c) state which parts of the writing process may use AI, for example brainstorming but not drafting, or rephrasing a few sentences but not inventing arguments or conclusions; and

(d) require students to disclose any AI use on homework and essays, naming the tool and what they used it for.

our district recommends that teachers in grades K-8 do not allow any AI tools that are not explicitly authorized by the district as part of a curriculum.

3. AI in grading

Teachers may use AI tools to help grade student work as long as they disclose this to students.

A student who believes an AI-produced grade is unfair or incorrect may ask the teacher to review it within ten school days. If the student is still not satisfied, they may appeal to the head of the teacher’s department, who will review the work without relying on AI.

4. Privacy and approved tools

Only AI tools approved by our district may be used with students or student data. Before approval, each tool will be reviewed for compliance with FERPA, COPPA, and state student-privacy law. Approved vendors must agree not to use student data to train AI models or for advertising, and to delete student data on request and when the contract ends.

our district will keep a public list of approved tools.

5. AI detection

AI-detection software may be used as one part of an academic integrity review, but a detection result cannot be the sole evidence that a student violated this policy.

Before any finding, the student will be told of the concern, shown the evidence, and given a chance to respond, for example by walking through their drafts, version history, or reasoning.

6. Equal access

If AI use is allowed or required on an assignment, required tools must be made available to all students, at no cost, with time to use them at school for students who lack access at home.

7. Annual review

The Board of Education will review this policy at least once a year. Before making meaningful changes, our district will consult students, parents and guardians, and teachers, for example through surveys, a public comment period, or an AI committee with student members.

Adopted [date] by the Board of Education.

How to propose this policy

Where a rule lives decides who can change it. A board policy is voted on by your district’s school board and covers every school. A student handbook rule is set by your principal and covers one school. Start with whichever moves faster where you are; many students start with their principal and take a working handbook rule to the board later. Pick which one at the top of the page, and the slides and email below change to match.

  1. Find who decides.For a handbook rule, that’s your principal. For a board policy, email the superintendent and one board member, ideally whoever chairs the policy committee. Our school board guide shows how to find them.
  2. Bring numbers.A short survey of how students use AI, and how many have been accused of using it when they didn’t, makes the case better than any argument. Nationally, 51% of students worry about being falsely accused of using AI (RAND, 2025). Your results go on slide 3.
  3. Send the email.Use the template below, and paste the whole policy from above under your signature.
  4. Present it.Ask for 15 minutes, or sign up for public comment at a board meeting. The slides take about ten minutes; bring printed copies of the policy to hand out.
  5. Follow up.A week later, ask what happens next: when the policy committee will see it, or when it could go into the handbook. Offer to join whoever reviews it.

The slides

Twelve slides with your school or district’s name filled in. Open them to change any text, present full screen, or save a PDF.

A proposal

A clear AI policy for our district

Rules that preserve trust around AI use in classrooms and across the community.

[Your name] · [Grade or role] · [Date]

1

Nationally, students already use AI. The rules aren’t clear.

51%of students worry about being falsely accused of using AI
16%were accused, or know someone who was
34%of teachers say their school has an academic-integrity policy on AI

Source: RAND national surveys of students and teachers, 2025.

2

What students at our district told us

__%use AI for schoolwork at least once a week
__%aren’t sure what AI use is allowed in their classes
__%were accused of using AI, or know someone who was

We surveyed [number] students in [month].

3

Section 1 of 7

Tests and essays

  • No AI on tests, quizzes, or exams unless the teacher explicitly allows it.
  • No using AI to complete an entire written assignment.
AI
4

Section 2 of 7

Classroom use

  • Each teacher sets the AI rules for their class, in the syllabus and on any assignment that differs.
  • High school: AI to explain concepts, not to do homework; clear limits on AI in writing.
  • Students disclose any AI use, naming the tool and what they used it for.
  • Grades K-8: only AI tools approved as part of the curriculum.
AI in this classExplain conceptsBrainstorm ideasDo the homeworkName the tool used
5

Section 3 of 7

AI in grading

  • Teachers may use AI to help grade, as long as they tell students.
  • A student can ask the teacher to review an AI-produced grade within ten school days.
  • If it still seems wrong, the department head reviews the work without AI.
AI-assisted grade: B−ask within 10 school daysTeacher reviews itstill unfair?Department head, no AI
6

Section 4 of 7

Privacy and approved tools

  • Only approved tools, checked against FERPA, COPPA, and state privacy law.
  • Vendors can’t train AI or advertise with student data, and must delete it on request.
  • A public list of approved tools.
FERPACOPPAState law
7

Section 5 of 7

AI detection

  • A detector result is never the only evidence against a student.
  • Before any finding, the student is told the concern and shown the evidence.
  • They get a chance to respond with their drafts, version history, or reasoning.
61%of essays by non-native English speakers were flagged as AI-written, on average across seven popular detectors

Source: Liang et al., “GPT detectors are biased against non-native English writers,” 2023.

8

Section 6 of 7

Equal access

  • If an assignment allows or requires AI, every student gets the tool free.
  • Students without access at home get time to use it at school.
Same tools for every studentfree, with time to use them at school
9

Section 7 of 7

Annual review

  • AI changes every few months, so the policy is reviewed every year.
  • Students, parents and guardians, and teachers are consulted before meaningful changes.
Every year
10

Similar policies in other schools

  • Prince George’s County, MDReviews its AI policy every year, with students invited onto the work group.
  • South Orange-Maplewood, NJTeachers state AI rules up front; students get due process before any finding.
  • Wichita, KSIf an assignment allows AI, the tools must be available to all students.
  • California and OhioState model policies: in California, detectors can’t be the only basis for discipline; in Ohio, students sit on the AI workgroup.

Tennessee, Ohio, Maryland, Virginia, and Oklahoma now require districts to adopt an AI policy.

11

What we’re asking

  1. 1Refer this draft to the board’s policy committee.
  2. 2Put it on a board agenda for a first reading by [month].
  3. 3Include student members on the committee that reviews it each year.
12

The email

Email template

Subject: A proposal for a clear AI policy for our district

Dear [Board member or superintendent name],

My name is [your name], and I’m a [grade] student at [school]. I’m writing to ask the board to adopt a clear policy on how students and teachers use AI.

Right now, [what students are seeing, for example: rules change from class to class, and students aren’t sure what’s allowed]. In a survey of [number] students, [result]. Nationally, 51% of students worry about being falsely accused of using AI (RAND, 2025).

I’ve drafted a policy based on ones other districts and states have already adopted. It covers seven things: no AI on tests or to write whole assignments, clear AI rules from each teacher, open AI grading with a way to appeal, a privacy review for every tool, never relying on an AI detector alone, equal access, and a yearly review with students, parents, and teachers. I’ve pasted the full text below.

Could I have 15 minutes to walk you through it? I’m free [day and time] or [day and time], or any time [range of days] that works for you. I’d also be glad to present it during public comment at the next board meeting.

Thank you,
[Your name]
[Grade], [school]
[Email or phone]